Being that I’m a lover of Mexican food, how could I possibly not celebrate Cinco de Mayo? 
This Cinco de Mayo I wanted to make something Mexican, but the only ingredients I had on hand were half Mexican.
Cheddar Cheese ~ yes, Mexican
Jalapeno ~ yes, Mexican
Cream Cheese ~ not so Mexican
Bread ~ so NOT Mexican!
Close enough.
Y’all know Jalapeno Poppers are my biggest weakness when it comes to junk food, and I shamelessly admit that I usually have a box of the cream cheese kind in my freezer, but I only eat them like once a month. I know, I’m so BAD!
After making my own Baked Jalapeno Poppers stuffed with Cream Cheese, I wanted to make something similar in the form of a sandwich, if you will. 
It’s ooey, gooey, a little unhealthy, but oh so good! Now all I need is some tequila to wash it down.
Happy Cinco de Mayo everyone… eat, drink, & be merry!!!
INGREDIENTS (makes 4 sandwiches, maybe 5):
- Jalapeno – 12 (sliced in half & deseeded & broiled)
- Neufchatel Cream Cheese – 3 ounces (or use 1/3 less fat)
- Milk 2% Reduced Fat – 2 to 3 tbsp (depends on how diluted you want the cream cheese spread, start with 2 tbsp)
- Garlic Powder – 1/2 tsp
- Cayenne Pepper – 1/4 tsp (omit if you can’t handle heat)
- Black Pepper – 1/4 tsp
- Salt to taste – 1/3 tsp (use less or more)
- Medium Cheddar Cheese – 1/2 cup (grated for cream cheese mixture)
- Medium Cheddar Cheese – 1 cup (grated… use how much cheese you’d like for the sandwich)
- Unsalted Butter – just to glaze the skillet
- Whole Wheat Multigrain Bread – 2 slices per sandwich
DIRECTIONS:
1. Set the oven to BROIL HIGH!
2. Start by slicing and deseeding the jalapeno poppers. You really need 12 poppers at least, I ended up doing this in 2 batches since I wasn’t sure how many to use initially.
3. Into the oven for 15 to 20 minutes, keep checking after 10 minutes on broil.
CREAM CHEESE SPREAD
4. In the meantime, make the cream cheese spread. Add cream cheese and milk to a bowl.
5. Season with garlic powder, cayenne pepper, black pepper, and salt.
6. Mix.
7. Grate enough cheddar cheese for the cream cheese spread and the sandwiches.
8. Add 1/2 cup of cheddar cheese to the cream cheese spread.
9. Mix well. Check for seasonings at this point.
10. Check on the jalapeno poppers, this is what they should look like. Love the taste of broiled jalapeno. 
ASSEMBLE
11. Spread the cream cheese spread on each slice of bread. 
12. Top a slice of bread with cheese.
13. Then top with jalapeno.
14. Heat a cast-iron skillet on low to medium heat (dial 3). Once hot, glaze with very little butter. I highly recommend using a cast-iron skillet for that enhanced flavor.
15. Gently place both slices of bread on the skillet. 
16. After about a minute or 2, top the jalapeno with cheddar cheese.
17. Place the other slice of bread over the cheese.
18. Cook on both sides until done. Split in half and serve immediately. 
19. Repeat the assemble steps for the next sandwich. Enjoy!
TELL ME: Are you celebrating Cinco de Mayo? What are you eating, drinking, doing? Where you eating out? Share the love!
A foodie who is passionate about living a healthy-ish lifestyle, cooking, and traveling. You'll find a mix of everything here and lots of seasonal content. I moved from Jersey City leaving behind my family & friends to beautiful Southern California for love. I'm adjusting to the laid-back SoCal lifestyle and learning a lot about myself along the way. Come join me on a soul searching journey and I'll tell YOU "what's cooking" through my love for food, fashion, and travel.
Anything cheese, yes please !! I am huge cheese fan, this is the best! Been eating so much cheese now back in Australia !!
Amelia – so great to hear that you are back in Australia.. you can really enjoy all the cheese you want now. This sandwich is SO good! Try it and let me know. 🙂
I love anything cheesy & Mexian, including the sound of this sandwich :)! The only thing I would add is a side of salsa for dipping purposes! My Cinco De Mayo involved a friend's surprise party which was Cinco De Mayo themed…and hence mid-day margaritas were consumed. I had a burrito bowl with quinoa & eggs for dinner because it only seemed right ;)!
Me too, Khushboo. Cheese and Mex go hand in hand, think I'll be eating Mexican tonight again for dinner. Salsa would make a difference too. So great you celebrated Cinco de Mayo in Mumbai, didn't know it was popular there. I love margaritas, they are my fave! Burrito bowl with quinoa sounds really nice.
Saw this post over the weekend and was seriously craving grilled cheese the rest of the time. YUM! We didn't do anything for Cinco de Mayo this year. Too busy and tired from the move. However, you better believe that we will be fiesta"ing" it up next year!
Awwww.. thanks Parita. You're in Miami, everyday is Cinco de Mayo. 🙂 The Mex food there is so good. Hope you are all settled in after your move. Can't wait to read about it and see pictures.
OMG I didn't do anything for cinco de mayo. I might just have to have a belated celebration with margaritas and your recipe. Are the jalapenos still really spicy after broiling? (I'm scared of a lot of spice but I do love the kick).
Lauren – weren't you up in Maine this weekend? You ate all these crawly things. 🙂 The jalapenos are seriously toned down after broiling them. Since you are paranoid, I would skip the cayenne pepper, but don't skimp on the jalapeno, once deseeded and broiled, they are perfect. I could eat them broiled with no issues. Hope you try it.
oh my this looks so good..I did not do much Cinco de Mayo but made Mexican Lasagna with guac. Posting recipe tomorrow 🙂
Thanks Dixya. Mexican Lasagna sounds nice, can't wait to see your version tomorrow. 🙂 Texas must be fun on Cinco de Mayo, there is no denying that.
Ohmyyum! That's decadence at it's best!
ps: I don't cook in cast iron. Can you believe it? In fact, I don't own one!! Yikes!
Kiran – It is so yum! You should totally get a cast-iron skillet, the one I bought is Lodge, and they are only $30, so affordable and excellent excellent quality. There is definitely a difference in taste.
Mmmm, I love this delicious looking sandwich, perfect for Mexican festivities 😀
Cheers
CCU
Thanks GU. Thanks.. it was yummy, but Mex inspired. 🙂
holy smokes, this looks INCREDIBLE- how have I never had this before!
Thank you. I love jalapeno poppers, hence the idea came to me, sort of a healthier version, if you will. 🙂
Oh my goodness, that looks amazing! I love grilled cheese so I know I'll love this. Give me a big bowl of soup with this and I'm a happy camper! 🙂
Anne – It's like a step up from grilled cheese, just a whole new level of flavor. I know right, soup would help, but just half a sandwich was super filling. 🙂
Oh dear, that is cheese heaven. Seriously.
Thanks, means so much coming from the chef herself. 🙂
That sandwich looks absolutely delicious!
Thanks Pam.
Now THAT is a grilled cheese! Absolutely outrageous. I bet it's soooo delicious!
I know.. thanks Georgia. It was really good.
My husband just peered over my shoulder and asked me to make this. 🙂 It looks INCREDIBLE!
Kiersten, your comment put a smile on my face. I'm so glad he approved and hope you make this. It's amazing!
We love jalapeno poppers over here and I think we'd adore them even more in grilled cheese! What an awesome sandwich!
Joanne – Thanks.. cheese and cream cheese adds depths of flavor to this sandwich.. hope you try it.
OMG, these sandwiches look awesome. I had something similar in TN this Christmas that I wanted to replicate and these look very similar if not better to the ones I had. For sure I will be making these sandwiches very very soon 🙂 By the way the pasta with the creamy mushroom sauce was delish. A keeper for sure and I will be posting the recipe soon! Can't wait to try these puppies, pinning 🙂
Miryam – thanks so much.. I'm so glad you enjoyed the Mushroom Pasta.. it was awesome. I wanna make more variations of it. Can't wait until you post your version. Wow, you ate these in TN, I'm sure the food scene there is great, ultimate Southern comfort food. Thanks!
Yum! I want some!
http://www.rsrue.blogspot.com
Haha.. me too!!!
First time at your blog space and I loved this yummy sandwich that is oozing of oomph!!!
Happy following you…do visit my blog when you get time 🙂
Thanks.. will check you out too. I love how the cheese oozes out too. 🙂
Ooey, gooey , cheesy and spicy, what more can one ask for in a sandwich. This looks insanely delicious!
I know.. the ooey gooey and cheesy take away from the spicy.. it's amazing!